Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Alex Peaks3 years ago

Thanks Johnathan. Don't lose hope, the point is the fight against injustice, not the victory.

Avatar

Linda Lou Kelley3 years ago

Thanks for all you do, Jonathan! First, I'm grateful because I've learned so much from you, as have many others. (For example, how a two-state solution sounds great until you realize there's no second state left.) Second, it's always reassuring to know that there is still at least one person left who sees all this tragedy, still gives a đź’©, and is working skillfully to bring the perpetrators to light. Finally, you go straight to the heart of the matter and explain so clearly and vividly.

Please take good care and get the rest and recreation that you need.

Avatar

Donald Koller3 years ago

The ”Substack Nazi Problem” is ancillary to the bigger problem, which is that seemingly average Americans are listening to and considering Nazi propaganda. Those who recognize Nazi propaganda SHOULD point it out to others. It could be one's own family members, or an individual could tell as many as will listen. Katz did, and has been pilloried for it. Yet, it is true and factual that Nazi propaganda exists there, because the publishers removed some of it.

These ideas are supposed to be verboten for individuals to seriously consider. When discussed philosophically, the parameters must be rigid. Yet, this is what we see taking place in social and mainstream media, absent any guardrails. This stuff is supposed to be organically banned, absent from our discourse. Yet, here we sit writing about it.

Seemingly many did not learn the lesson of Nazi Germany. That also needs to be pointed out by those who recognize it. Perhaps Katz has provided an example of the lesson we all should know.

Avatar

Alex Gil3 years ago

Lol. I'm gonna be laughing for a while about Freddie deBoer's self-own. Good times.

Avatar

Jonathan M. KatzAuthor3 years ago

He's incredible.

Avatar

Geoffrey Anderson3 years ago

Dear god, what a bunch of wankers.

Avatar

Geoffrey Anderson3 years ago

I clicked on the link about Transphobia and the read on Jesse Singal was eye opening. Seeing how much he and his coterie of wankers have infected just about any discussion about the Nazi issue at Substack, I am not surprised by what I read. I just got nothing, but that man needs help.

Avatar

Nancy Krempa3 years ago

I, too, have followed the "Nazi" controversy and found that you were absolutely right in your Atlantic article. Too bad others cannot see the forest for the White Supremacy, but it's there... big as life, festering like an overgrown ulcer, and doing nothing to bolster the reputation of Substack. I was going to start writing my own newsletter there but, following all that brouhaha, have decided to take my thoughts elsewhere - except when addressing the authors I follow who are still on that site.

Take what time you need, do what's necessary to recharge, and your loyal readers will be here when you feel like writing more.

Be safe, and warm, and enjoy those kiddos!! <3

Avatar

Jonathan M. KatzAuthor3 years ago

Thank you! And thanks always for your support.

Avatar

David Roberts3 years ago

Jonathan,

I've followed the "Nazis" on Substack controversy closely. I've read your article and the articles on your article.

Your article was indeed inaccurate and sloppy. It may have helped your career, at least in the short run, but it caused a great and needless waste of words and energy.

And upon investigation, it lacked any clarity of any kind.

David Roberts

Avatar

Jonathan M. KatzAuthor3 years ago

Please, be more specific. What was inaccurate?

Avatar

dan tynan3 years ago

here, allow me to badly paraphrase Camus regarding Sisyphus. Sure, it’s a drag having to push that big boulder up the hill for all of eternity, but at least he had a pleasant walk down the hill. Or something like that.

Enjoy your downtime.

Avatar

Jonathan M. KatzAuthor3 years ago

Cheers.