Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Jamie Baldwin2 years ago

Thank you for this. Bret Stephens’ column was a perfect example of the cheerleading by noncombatants that’s an essential ingredient of war. The logic of war is that eventually, with sufficient death and destruction, people on one side will stop cheering. Today, war doesn’t ultimately work as a way of pursuing politics by other means because atomic weapons make victory impossible. In the end, as you put it, “Bret will have to take off his pretend bomber helmet and die with the rest of us.” It seems to be taking some time for humanity to realize that war is obsolete. In the meantime, we keep trying to use it in limited ways. No, it’s the same dead end whether pursued to its ultimate conclusion or not. Who’s winning in Gaza? Heaven help us. Lord deliver us from cosplaying columnists.

Avatar

S Peter Davis2 years ago

You'd probably be very unsurprised to learn that Taibbi is going absolutely ballistic about the Trump verdict, even resorting to "politicians falsify records to hide things all the time, it's normal and no big deal."

Avatar

Jonathan M. Katz2 years ago

You are correct, I would not be!

Avatar

Elsie H.2 years ago

If we take Jabotinsky’s word for it, the better comparison for what’s happening in Gaza might be the California Genocide in the wake of US conquest.

And that comparison makes a direct connection back to Balaji Srinivasan’s recent “tech Zionism” proposal to “ethnically cleanse” San Francisco…

(…from Sacramento to the sea, the Bay Area will be free?)

Avatar

Elsie H.2 years ago

I would respect Balaji a lot more if, say, he actually personally lived on a yacht in international waters off the coast of Northern California, like a decent Bond villain, but noooooo… instead he’s just a covetous loser. Go back to Long Island where you belong!

Avatar

Jonathan M. Katz2 years ago

Yeah that's a good parallel.