Yesterday, in a landmark ruling, the International Court of Justice found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya people. It is the first time the court has found a state responsible for committing genocide under part of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. (See Footnote 1 for details on past cases.1)
This isn’t just a major setback for the Southeast Asian country also known as Burma. It is a shot across the bow of any country that thinks the seventy-eight-year-old convention has no power over national governments. And for one country in particular, facing its own genocide case at The Hague, the details of the ruling only get worse from there. In short, the new ruling undermines most of the bad arguments Israel’s defenders have used against the charge of genocide. Here are a few of them:
Subscribe to The Racket—free to start reading, paid to keep it going.
Argument 1: Death Toll
One of the most common “debunking” arguments is that Israeli forces simply haven’t killed enough people in Gaza to count as a genocide. Versions of this have been put forward by Bret Stephens (“If the Israeli government’s intentions and actions are truly genocidal … why hasn’t it been more methodical and vastly more deadly?” he wrote last year) and his former protégée, Bari Weiss. Scott Galloway, on the Pivot podcast he hosts with Kara Swisher, tried to put it in terms of percentages during a recent pre-election interview with Michigan senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed:
Going from 15 million to nine million Jews in Europe was a genocide — 40%. Wiping out 70% of the Tutsi population, that was a genocide. A third of the Cambodian population — that was genocide. 3% of the Gazan population has been killed, and typically a genocide doesn’t involve shipping in polio vaccines [NOTE: See footnotes2], or 2,500 calories a day3, or dropping leaflets, or leaving voicemails telling civilians to vacate an area where they have been purposely embedded in military targets4. Do you understand why Jews such as myself find your description of what’s happening in Israel and in Gaza as a genocide disqualifying?
The problem with that argument, in addition to Galloway’s errors and the fact that it’s fundamentally disgusting, is that neither the jurist who came up with the idea of genocide, Raphael Lemkin (see footnote), nor the Genocide Convention say anything about a minimum threshold of deaths, as a percentage or otherwise. In fact, the lack of any consideration for the number of dead has been a criticism of the concept of genocide made by human-rights advocates over the years.
And, indeed, the ICJ just dismissed that argument entirely. Its finding that Myanmar violated the prohibition against “intentionally killing members” of a “national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such,” was based on the killing of an estimated 10,000 Rohingya, who, in the judges’ own words, “constituted 1.2 per cent of the targeted population.” In Gaza, the official number is 75,586 Palestinians killed, and counting. The Brown University Costs of War project found that more than 10 percent of the prewar population of Gaza has been killed or injured.
The ICJ said of Myanmar: “The Court observes that, while a high relative number of deaths may well be an important factor from which to infer genocidal intent, a comparatively lower percentage of deaths does not, by itself, necessarily preclude a finding of genocidal intent.”
Argument 2: They Didn’t Try to Kill Everyone
As noted in the context of Galloway’s argument above, Israel’s defenders like to argue that its “security forces had, and did not avail themselves of, opportunities to destroy [the Arab] population.” They also note that the war was undertaken in response to “the [Hamas] attacks,” and that this “imposed geographic and other constraints on the opportunities that were available” to them.
Just kidding! Not that Israeli officials and defenders don’t make arguments exactly like those — they routinely do. (Benjamin Netanyahu memorably said last year: “If we had wanted to commit genocide, it would have taken exactly one afternoon.”) It’s just that the quotations above are from the ICJ ruling on the Rohingya genocide, cited or paraphrased from statements made by the Burmese government — just sub out the bracketed terms for “Bengalis” and the “Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army,” the armed Islamist Rohingya militia based in northern Rakhine State. (Much as Israel does with Palestinians, Myanmar officials deny that the Rohingya are a group or nationality at all, claiming that they are latter-day invaders from Bangladesh.)
Again, bad news. In its finding, the ICJ says: “In the Court’s view, a reasonable inference of genocidal intent does not depend on evidence that the perpetrators made every effort to maximize the level of harm that they caused to the protected group … the Court finds that the fact that Myanmar did not take every opportunity it had to destroy members of the Rohingya group does not preclude an inference of genocidal intent.”
I should note that six judges dissented jointly on this exact point, citing the Croatia case. But the majority disagreed. And again, the Hague court reminded all parties: “There is no requirement of a minimum number of victims, so long as the acts are those set forth in one of the provisions of Article II [of the Genocide Convention] and one or more victims are members of the protected groups.”
Argument 3: Dolus Specialis
Israel’s lawyers at the ICJ have leaned heavily on the requirement of dolus specialis, or “specific intent [to destroy the group in whole or in part]”. They may be hoping for a repeat of the Bosnia case, in which Serbia was cleared of committing genocide but found to have failed to prevent it (see Footnote 1). There, the court said it was not enough for genocidal intent to be inferred from a “pattern of … atrocities committed over many communities, over a lengthy period.”
That court did say that, in the absence of a formal plan, a “pattern of conduct” could be “accepted as evidence,” but only if …
Upgrade to Premium to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber to The Racket to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
UpgradeAlready a subscriber? Sign in
A subscription gets you:
- Get exclusive posts available only to premium subscribers
- Full access to archived issues since 2019
- Behind the scenes insights and first looks at Jonathan's upcoming projects
- Keep independent journalism alive. Don't let the bastards get us down.

